Peter Merrill, Campus Carrier news editor
Earlier this month, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi defied the Chinese government’s wishes and visited Taiwan with five other Democratic house members. Since then, other United States officials have visited the island and senator Marsha Blackburn called the unrecognized territory a country, despite the United States’ official stance. In response, Chinese officials said that the U.S would be responsible for any further consequences.
Matt Stanard, professor of history, briefly recounted the history of Chinese-Taiwanese relations and how the latter split from the former.
“In 1949 the Communist Party won the civil war in China after World War Two,” Stanard said. “The communists had been fighting against the nationalists, led at the time by Chiang Kai-shek who had been in power in China going back to the interwar period. Basically, the communists triumph, the nationalists lose and essentially retreated to the island of Taiwan.”
For a time, Taiwan was an authoritarian state, but after reforms were implemented in the late twentieth century, it became a democracy. According to Freedom House’s global freedom scores, Taiwan is 94% free as opposed to China’s 9% or the United States’ 83%.
John Hickman, professor of international affairs, said that since China started to become more capitalist after Mao Zedong’s death, the government has been seeking new ways to justify their regime. Chinese history is fraught with suffering as a result of disunity, and so the Chinese Communist Party holds unity in high regard, and according to Hickman, it uses promises of unity to legitimize their regime. Because Taiwan is such an effective democracy, and claims to be the true “Republic of China,” the island poses an existential threat to the mainland despite its small size.
Although China and Taiwan have always been at odds and have always sought to subsume the other, recent signs show that China might be preparing to act. Kirsten Taylor, professor of international affairs, said that China has been demonstrating their power through military exercises in much the same way that Russia did before invading Ukraine and with its crackdown on Hong Kong’s liberty in 2019 and 2020.
“I think [the war in Ukraine] provided an opening for China in that it made it look possible for China to maybe begin to take some actions to bring Taiwan back into the fold,” said Taylor. “Given that the U.S has not actively stepped in to stop Russia, I’m sure China’s leaders are thinking they might have an opportunity to get away with, should they deem it the right time, to get away with formally bringing Taiwan back into China.”
Stanard said that the time for China to act might be soon as its population is rapidly shrinking and aging.
“China is a particular position in this decade, said Stanard. “It is doing very well economically, but there are these sort of troublesome signs for China. We might be approaching peak China and it might be that China will do something now before this window closes.”
Stanard said that China’s protestations against the Nancy Pelosi and other senators’ visits made sense from a certain vantage point.
“Can you imagine if the second in command in China said, ‘I’m going to visit Cuba, support a communist country’?” Standard said. “And the U.S sent clear signals that said ‘do not do that, this is just off the coast of Florida, you don’t have any business here, this is our neck of the woods. If they went to Cuba and successfully pulled off that trip, I imagine you would have a kind of uproar about that. In response, the U.S might have some kind of show of force.”
Hickman said that in effect, the visits of United States officials to Taiwan help to make the Taiwanese feel more secure, even though the United States has not officially recognized Taiwan since the Nixon presidency. Hickman said that despite their ambiguity, the United States and its allies are firmly on the side of the Taiwanese, and the United States have promised to defend the island from the mainland.
“Taiwan’s the real thing,” said Hickman. “I think we should be interested in the fate of other democracies.”




Leave a Reply